Skip to main content
Popular

Buy and sell used halloween in Manhattan

    Terror Tower Party Game with Halloween Glasses

    $8
    East Harlem

    Women's Captivating Miss Red Halloween Costume

    $49
    Hell's Kitchen

    Halloween Boo Snow Globe with Stack of Books

    $15
    Harlem

    Variety of Puzzles: Ceaco, Dowdle, Galison

    $24
    Midtown Manhattan

    Halloween bowl

    $20
    Harlem

    Cawing Halloween crow

    $25
    Morningside Heights

    New cosmetics lot (13) + Ipsy Bag HEMPZ ESTATE Naked Pūrlisse

    $19
    Financial District

    Mean Girls Halloween Costume

    $14.30
    Lenox Hill

    Women's blk/silver Halloween costume

    $29
    Chelsea

    Hot Topic Kitty Choker Tail Halloween accessories Faux leather

    $6
    Financial District

    Limited edition Halloween Card queen deluxe costume

    $85
    Hell's Kitchen

    Wall Hanging Decoration

    $14
    Theater District

    Brand new totally spooky

    $5
    Washington Heights

    Brand new totally spooky

    $5
    Washington Heights

    Brand new totally spooky

    $5
    Washington Heights

    Ventige hat for Chinese new year dance

    $15
    Bowery

    Toy Story 4 Alien Head Costume

    Free
    Hudson Yards

    Adorable Bat-Winged Sloth Plush Toy

    $5
    Upper West Side

    NWB MAC Nail Polish Shadow AC3 🧡

    $5
    Financial District

    ❄️ NWOT 0 XS S Red Bodycon Pencil Dress Spaghetti Strap Dress

    $9
    Financial District

    Red Solid Plastic Headband #freecycle

    Free
    Financial District
    Sold

    Simpsons Halloween Burger King Toys

    $10
    Harlem
    Sold

    Funko Pop! Simpsons Halloween Treehouse of Horror

    $25
    Harlem
    Sold

    Harley Quinn Suicide Squad Halloween Costume for Women

    $99
    Hell's Kitchen
    Sold

    100s of Halloween Stickers Brand New

    Free
    Hell's Kitchen
    Sold

    Three-Candle Skeleton Hand Candelabra LED Lights Halloween Decor

    $5
    Upper West Side
    Sold

    Halloween bunny 20.00

    $15
    East Harlem
    Sold

    Halloween 🎩 hat

    $5
    Ditmars Steinway
    Sold

    Halloween glow wand toy#freecycle

    Free
    Stuyvesant Town
    Sold

    Official Harry Potter Gryffindor Halloween Costume Kids Medium

    $27
    Upper West Side
    Sold

    Wonder Woman Halloween Kids Costume

    $18
    Upper West Side
    Sold

    Halloween Costume Accessories Bundle #freecycle

    Free
    Upper West Side
    Sold

    Halloween costume girl 8-10Y

    $5
    Upper West Side
    Sold

    Black Panther Shuri Halloween Costume Child Size Medium

    $27
    Upper West Side
    Sold

    Halloween Carmen Sandiego costume

    $35
    Battery Park City
    Sold

    Dog halloween costume

    $10
    Hudson Yards
    Sold

    Halloween costume.

    $30
    Morningside Heights
    Sold

    Halloween costume for girl 3.4ft / snow white dress

    $5
    Upper West Side
    Sold

    Halloween costume for girl 3.8ft / disney dress

    $5
    Upper West Side
    Sold

    Official Disney Star Wars Rey Halloween Costume Size 7/8

    $18
    Upper West Side
    Sold

    Studio M Halloween Witch Tote Bag #freecycle

    Free
    Hamilton Heights
    Sold

    Harley Girl High Heels Boots Villain Squad

    $49
    Hell's Kitchen
    Sold

    #freecycle Halloween Cat Ear Clips

    Free
    East Village
    Sold

    BN SCREAMING DOOR PAD

    $2
    Washington Heights
    Sold

    #IWD free give away

    Free
    Morningside Heights
    Sold

    Set of 3 Witch Wine Glasses #freecycle

    Free
    Chelsea
    Sold

    Starbucks (great for costume)

    $19
    Garment District
    Sold

    Hulk mask with green body paint for adults

    $5
    Ditmars Steinway
    Sold

    Spiderman Children’s Costume (NEW)

    $15
    Sugar Hill
    Sold

    🌏 Dinosaur Costume

    $10
    Stuyvesant Town
    Sold

    Ladies Police Officer Costume

    $75
    Chelsea
    Sold

    U.S. Army Camouflage Costume

    $60
    Chelsea
    Sold

    #freecycle Mario Hat

    Free
    East Harlem
    Sold

    Large Plush Skeleton Dog Toy

    $8
    Upper West Side
    Sold

    Red 4 inch heels size 10 women

    $20
    Lower East Side
    Sold

    Suicide Squad The Joker Jacket Costume

    $35
    Hamilton Heights
    Sold

    Pink Light Up Cat Ear Headphones with Microphone

    $15
    Greenwich Village
    Sold

    Wireless Earbuds Bluetooth Ear-Buds in-Ear Headphones

    $25
    Central Park
    Discover great finds today!
    Get the app