Used Puzzles for Sale
- $18Misitu Book City 1000 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle7mi · Nyack
- $5EuroGraphics 1000 Piece Globetrotter Canada Puzzle26mi · Upper East Side
- $10Hot air balloon puzzle27mi · Hell's Kitchen
- $9MasterPieces Nutcracker Suite 1000 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle30mi · Lower East Side
- $4Vermont Christmas Company Day of the Dead 1000 Piece Puzzle26mi · Upper East Side
- $5Galison 500 Piece Foil Puzzle24mi · Morningside Heights
- $401008-Piece Christmas Advent Calendar Jigsaw Puzzle Set27mi · Upper East Side
- $40Jigsaw Puzzle Advent Calendar 2024 1008 Pieces 24-Day Christmas27mi · Upper East Side
It’s easier in the apps- $250Dior Exclusive 500-Piece Puzzle25mi · Upper West Side
- $15Saja Boys and K-Pop Demon Hunters 60-Piece Puzzles All 425mi · East Harlem
- $8Wood City Wooden Tetris Puzzle28mi · Midtown Manhattan
- $8Galison 500 Piece Motel Sign Puzzle26mi · Upper East Side
- $7500 Piece Puzzle26mi · Upper East Side
- SoldFree 🎁Hello Kitty Pack of Four 100-Piece Puzzles25mi · Upper West Side
- $10Mudpuppy Jumbo Puzzle - Depths of the Sea26mi · Upper West Side
- $10 or tradeNWB Music Through The Ages Guitars 1000 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle30mi · Lower East Side
- $10brain squared game27mi · Hell's Kitchen
- $4NEW✨Boombox Jiggies 44-Piece Puzzle27mi · Midtown East
- Sold$4PieceRelax New York City 1008-Piece Jigsaw Puzzle27mi · Lenox Hill
- $19LEGO Minifigure Faces 1000-Piece Puzzle28mi · Midtown East
- $3EuroGraphics Elephant & Baby 1000 Piece Puzzle26mi · Upper East Side
- $15Dinosaur Wooden Jigsaw Puzzle 🏈25mi · Manhattan Valley
- $15Wooden Farm Scene Kids Puzzle 🏈25mi · Manhattan Valley
- $15Jungle Animals Wooden Jigsaw Puzzle 🏈25mi · Manhattan Valley
- $15Underwater Scene Wooden Jigsaw Puzzle 🏈25mi · Manhattan Valley
- Sold$25Star Wars 4 Puzzle Pack 🏈25mi · Upper West Side
- $29🏈Hilma af Klint Puzzle Set27mi · Midtown East
- $20🏈Ian Shive Kodiak Refuge 1000 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle27mi · Midtown East
- $24🏈500-Piece Van Gogh Puzzle27mi · Midtown East
- $8Retro Fan Puzzles Vintage Football 500pc8mi · Ossining
- Sold$4Buffalo Games New York Panoramic Puzzle26mi · Upper East Side
- Sold$101000 Piece Puzzle26mi · Upper East Side
- $5NEW✨81-Piece Puzzle cat shape puzzle🧩27mi · Midtown East
- $101000 piece puzzles29mi · Bay Terrace
- SoldFree 🎁Raya, Graffiti Egypt, and Aurélia Durand Puzzles29mi · Flushing
- $10Rubik's Snake Puzzle Toy - Red, Black, Yellow26mi · Upper West Side
- Sold$10The World of Jane Austen 1000 Piece Puzzle26mi · Lincoln Square
- $7Disney Pixar Toy Story 4 Buzz Lightyear 3D Crystal Puzzle24mi · Longwood
- $6Retro Fan Puzzles Vintage Baseball 500 pc8mi · Ossining
- $15Perplexus Original 3D Labyrinth Sphere Puzzle Game26mi · Upper West Side
- Sold$10Secret Sanctuary Charley Harper 500 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle22mi · Washington Heights
- $17University of California 3D Wooden Puzzle24mi · East Harlem
- $5⚽️Disney Fairies 50 Piece Puzzle Tin31mi · Fresh Meadows
- $5⚽️SpongeBob SquarePants 50 Piece Puzzle31mi · Fresh Meadows
- $12Cobble Hill Family Pieces Easter Bunnies 350 Piece Puzzle27mi · Midtown East
- $2Tori Amos Jigsaw Puzzle Custom Made 500 Pieces ~1 Inch21mi · Fort Lee
- $30Netflix Stranger Things Premium Wooden Puzzle Dear Billy28mi · Jackson Heights
- $5Thomas Kinkade Disney Pocahontas 750 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle27mi · Astoria
- $7Disney Thomas Kinkade 2 Puzzles - 500 Pieces Each27mi · Astoria
- Sold$25Uprightas Summer Day On The River 438/501 Puzzle Pieces28mi · Jackson Heights
- SoldFree 🎁🌱 Set of 5 Mini Maze Puzzles28mi · Flushing
- SoldFree 🎁MB Puzzle 300 Piece EZ Grasp22mi · Washington Heights
- $9Crafthub Maltipoo Premium Wooden Puzzle - Medium/A4 - NEW28mi · Whitestone
- Sold$7Galison Winter Lights 500 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle24mi · Morningside Heights
- $20Star Wars Prime 3D Puzzles - 2 Pack28mi · Flushing
- $2Rubik's Cube Keychain28mi · Long Island City
- SoldFree 🎁Puzzles29mi · Greenwich Village
- Sold$20Puzzle Mania!: Wordle, Connections New York Times Games28mi · Jackson Heights




